Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: A Unique Perspective

Introduction

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is a play that has sparked mixed reactions among fans of J.K. Rowling’s iconic series. While some have embraced it as a nostalgic addition to the Harry Potter canon, others have criticized it for not living up to the original novels. In this article, we will explore the unique aspects of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, delving into its format, character development, and plot.

A Different Approach

A Play, Not a Novel

Unlike the original Harry Potter novels, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is not a traditional novel but a script for a stage play. This distinction is crucial to understanding the differences between the two. As a script, it lacks the descriptive details and fleshed-out settings found in novels. Scripts are dialogue-driven and rely on visual elements to bring the story to life. While this format may not appeal to everyone, it can still be an enjoyable read. The key is to approach it with the right expectations.

A Work of Elevated Fan Fiction

Another important aspect to consider is that Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is not solely the creation of J.K. Rowling. While she provided the story, the script was written by different authors. This collaboration sets the play apart from the original canon and should be taken into account when approaching the story. Rather than expecting a continuation of Rowling’s writing style and hallmarks, it is more accurate to view Cursed Child as an elevated form of fan fiction that has been blessed by Rowling herself.

Character Development and Relationships

The Adult Characters

One of the notable differences in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is the age of the characters. The events of the play take place after the epilogue in Deathly Hallows, with Harry, Hermione, Ron, and other original characters now adults. It is important to keep in mind that these characters have grown older, and their interactions and conversations reflect their maturity and life experiences. Their relationships with each other have evolved as well, as they now have their own families and responsibilities. While some reviewers have criticized the chemistry between the adult characters, it is only natural that their dynamics have changed over time.

Harry’s Role as a Father

A significant focus of the play is on Harry’s journey as a father. While he has a loving and supportive wife in Ginny, his middle child, Albus, presents him with challenges. Harry’s struggle to navigate fatherhood and guide Albus is a central plotline. The play explores whether Albus will follow in his famous father’s footsteps or forge his own path. Albus, unlike Harry, does not possess the same temperament or magical abilities. This deviation from the expected course allows for a unique exploration of Albus’ character.

Family Conflict and Redemption

The strained relationship between Harry and Albus is a source of conflict in the play. Albus, feeling the weight of his father’s legacy, rebels against Harry’s efforts to connect with him. This conflict leads to intense exchanges and emotional moments between the two. While some readers may find these interactions difficult to read, they provide a realistic portrayal of the challenges that can arise within a family. Both Harry and Albus must confront their own choices and learn what truly matters in life. Ultimately, they find redemption and reconcile their differences in a poignant scene.

Draco Malfoy and Scorpius

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child also explores the relationship between Draco Malfoy and his son, Scorpius. Draco, no longer a Death Eater, still faces the consequences of his past actions. Scorpius, burdened by his father’s reputation, struggles to forge his own identity. The play delves into whether one should dwell on the past or focus on the present and future. The dynamic between Draco and Scorpius offers a parallel to the conflict between Harry and Albus, further emphasizing the theme of redemption and growth.

Themes and Magical Elements

Legacy and Identity

One of the central themes in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is the exploration of legacy and identity. The play raises questions about whether individuals are destined to repeat the actions of their parents or if they can carve out their own paths. Albus, Scorpius, and other characters grapple with the weight of their family history and the expectations placed upon them. Through their journeys, the play emphasizes the importance of individual choices and the power to shape one’s own destiny.

Nods to the Original Canon

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child pays homage to the original series by including nods to beloved characters such as Madam Hooch, the Hogwarts Express trolley witch, and even Severus Snape. These references add a touch of nostalgia for fans and serve as reminders of the rich world Rowling created. The inclusion of these characters, albeit briefly, adds depth to the play and creates a sense of continuity with the original novels.

Criticisms and Contradictions

Character Depictions

While Harry Potter and the Cursed Child offers a unique perspective on the characters, some readers have raised concerns about the portrayal of certain characters. Ron is occasionally reduced to a comic foil, Hermione appears harsher than expected, and Harry’s verbal confrontations with Albus may seem out of character for someone who values family unity. These depictions, while intended to show the characters’ growth and maturity, may not resonate with all readers.

The Main Villain

One major criticism of the play revolves around the main villain, referred to as Character Z. The introduction of this character as Voldemort’s physical offspring contradicts the established characterization of Voldemort in the original series. Voldemort is depicted as lacking the capacity for love and human connection, making the idea of him having a child seem implausible. This contradiction detracts from the overall credibility of the story and raises questions about the creative decisions behind the play.

Convenient Magical Elements

Another point of contention in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is the use of time turners and their convenient application in the plot. Time turners, which were introduced in Prisoner of Azkaban, are controversial due to their tendency to create plot holes and convenient solutions. Some readers may find the reliance on time turners in the play to be unsatisfying and overly convenient. The execution of these magical elements can detract from the overall enjoyment of the story.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child offers a unique perspective on the beloved Harry Potter series. While it may not capture the magic and depth of the original novels, it presents an intriguing exploration of legacy, family dynamics, and personal growth. The play’s format

Popular Book Review:

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

“Gilead” by Marilynne Robinson (2004)

Atomic Habits by James Clare

Spare by Prince Harry